LocationAlhambra , CA
Despite Alhambra’s need for more revenue, the City Council took no position this week on the Schools & Communities First ballot initiative, which would change the basis for commercial property taxes, and probably increase them, if passed in November.
The Schools & Communities First ballot initiative, now Proposition 15 on the November ballot, would change the basis of commercial property taxes to current market value from the purchase price.
Councilwoman Katherine Lee spoke first in the cautious debate and weighed the merits of taxing business against funding for schools. She brought up her firsthand experience as a teacher with student desks breaking mid-lesson. But In the same breath, Lee said the threshold for taxing at current market value, as proposed by Prop 15, would probably hurt Alhambra businesses although the threshold in valuation would be $3 million. She said she had “to take a neutral position on this” and the city should “let the voters decide.”
Councilman Jeff Maloney, Vice mayor David Mejia and Mayor Ross Maza each had varied reasons for agreeing the city should take a neutral position.
Maza suggested that Prop 15 could be a precursor to “getting rid of Prop 13,” the 1978 constitutional amendment that severely limited property tax increases, intended to assist elderly homeowners who were being forced out of their homes by rising property taxes. However, it has applied to commercial and industrial property as well as residential even as values have increased with inflation.
Council member Adele Andrade-Stadler argued in favor of supporting Prop 15, noting after Maza’s comments about Prop 13 “don’t hold water” which caused a heated exchange.
In one public comment, Chris Olson, who will challenge Maloney in the November election, wrote a comment in favor of the proposition to support schools and economic recovery and to oppose systemic racism. Olson said the decline in public education and services were caused by the tax system, which she said most negatively impacted minority communities and continued system racism.
In other action, the council voted unanimously to write a letter of opposition to President Trump’s executive order to exclude from the Census count those living in the U.S. without permission. The census is mandated in the U.S. Constitution to count all persons living in the United States to determine proportional representation and taxation.
Council members all had individual reasons for supporting the letter. Mejia said he is not in city government for national issues but is concerned for local residents and “if you’re here, you should be counted.”
The city council heard a presentation for rezoning the City of Alhambra, which has not been done in totality since 1986. According to the zoning consultant there have been amendments since, but not an overhaul to align with the Vision 2040, Alhambra’s newest General Plan, land use map.
Martha Miller of Miller Planning Associates laid out steps for the council to take. Miller Planning Associates is in the background research and analysis phase. She said the city will not be ready to draft the regulations, development standards or administrative processes until late this year or early 2021. A draft of the new zoning code will not be ready until the late spring or summer of 2021.
Residents can sign up for zoning updates here.