fbpx

Join Our 30*30*30* Campaign!

Make A Donation

Donor Supporters

Elba Alonso de Ortega

I’m a lifelong resident of Alhambra and having a local newspaper, like Alhambra Source, is very important to me. It’s the only way to know the issues that will directly affect my day to day, where I live. That’s why I decided to support Alhambra Source with a monthly donation.

Efren Moreno, Former Alhambra Mayor

Thank you Alhambra Source for truly informing the residents of Alhambra.

Chris Olson

I support Alhambra Source as often as I can because I believe a free and independent press is vital to the democratic process. No other news outlet with high journalistic standards consistently covers the stories and issues that matter to our community.

Adele Andrade Stadler, Alhambra Mayor

The Source is a great independent newspaper that celebrates the communities and is not afraid to ask the tough questions!

Cliff Bender, Vice President, Alhambra Education Foundation

Alhambra Source is the ONLY independent news source covering the events, culture and government of our city. We need it to stay informed and aware!

Joyce & Oscar Amaro, Alhambra Preservation Group

We support Alhambra Source because this online news source is vitally important in engaging, informing and educating the residents of Alhambra.

Jose Aguayo

I support the Alhambra Source because journalism will always be part of that fourth branch of our democracy. The Alhambra Source provides me with news that helps me make informed decisions about issues that matter to me and my community. Thank you for the work you do.

Michael Lawrence, Alhambra Arts Commissioner

Keep bringing on the stories. The Source has given us so much and I am happy to donate to such an important part of our community.

Shirley Tatsuno

I support Alhambra Source for their detailed information about important Alhambra issues and compelling human-interest stories.

Alhambra’s Sikh Community May Be Displaced by Condo Development

  • Members of the west San Gabriel Valley's Sikh community attend the Sunday service at Alhambra's Sikh Gurdwara. The Sikh Community will have to vacate this building to make way for a new development, which they say they weren't properly informed about. Photo by Phoenix Tso.

  • A priest leads the prayer at Alhambra's Sikh Gurdwara in July. Photo by Phoenix Tso.

  • A member of Alhambra's Sikh Gurdwara hands out an offering at the end of the service. Photo by Phoenix Tso.

  • The Sikh Gurdwara includes a Sunday school where children can learn Punjabi, the primary language of India's Punjab region, where Sikhism originated. Photo by Phoenix Tso.

Location

Alhambra , CA United States

Every Sunday morning at least 100 people gather at the Sikh Gurdwara on Chapel Avenue located near the Sprouts supermarket and condominiums of the Alhambra Place shopping center. The children in the community learn Punjabi during Sunday school, while adults prepare a vegetarian meal for worshippers after the lunchtime service and socialize in the yard.

The worshippers trickle into a room, where the priest sings a prayer, accompanied by two instrumentalists playing the harmonium, which looks a small piano, and a tabla. He sings words praising the Guru Granth Sahib, considered the final guru in this religion. A book, which contains the fundamental beliefs of Sikhism, and written by the religion’s first 10 gurus, sits on an altar, covered by a cloth adorned with yellow fabric roses. Every so often, a worshipper approaches the altar and bows down in front of it, leaving a monetary offering.

The Sikh community has been worshipping on Chapel Avenue for much of the last 40 years. Now the community faces an uncertain future, as their building of worship is expected to be torn down to make way for a new development that they were not properly informed about, according to Santokh Singh, the Gurdwara’s president.

Founded in the Punjab region of India, Sikhism promotes belief in a monotheistic God, as well as the equality of all religions and people. Sikhs engage in many practices as part of their belief system, including an emphasis on community service and not cutting their hair to show respect for God’s creation.

Sikhism is one of the youngest world religions, and the fifth largest organized religion, with around 30 million worshippers. There are about 500,000 Sikhs living in the United States, mostly in New York and California. The Alhambra Gurdwara currently serves a community of around 300 people.

Around 15 years ago, the president of the temple moved his congregation to a bigger building in Walnut, 20 miles east of Alhambra. Sikhs, in this religious community, who lived in the west San Gabriel Valley thought Walnut was too far, and asked Singh to negotiate a one-year lease and then a month-to-month lease with Herald Lau, who owns the Gurdwara building and several adjacent properties. In summer 2015, they moved back in.

The location has multiple rooms for prayer and meditation, as well as living accommodations for the priests. The commercial kitchen allow the Gurdwara to serve vegetarian meals to its regulars, and anybody else who wants to visit and worship. The Gurdwara also has dry storage, a portable kitchen and propane and would be ready to prepare and serve meals in the event of a disaster. Every month, the community prepares and serves meals on Los Angeles’ Skid Row.

Singh said that the community views the building as special, since they have been able to hold on to it for so many years. “People are so connected to that building, because it’s so long that they pray here,” he told the Alhambra Source.

On June 17, 2019, a project involving 101 S. Chapel Ave, the address of the Gurdwara, came before Alhambra’s Planning Commission. Lau applied for a permit to develop the properties, including 101 to 107 S. Chapel Ave, into a 28-unit mixed-use condominium complex on the land, which would be a little over half an acre in size. Developing that parcel would mean tearing down the Gurdwara.

The city staff report for the development said the temple was vacant, and Planning Commissioner Scott Chan was also told this at the hearing, when he asked about the Gurdwara’s status. Later in the hearing, Commissioner Ron Sahu asked if the traffic study conducted around the property had included traffic from the Gurdwara when it was active. This is when Lau conceded that the Gurdwara was still active, but said that he had informed the community of the intended development, and was sensitive to the needs of the Sikh community, given how long they have been in Alhambra.

Lau has not returned multiple phone calls from the Alhambra Source requesting comment.

The Planning Commission voted 7 to 2 to approve the development. Sahu abstained over concerns with the traffic impacts and open space calculations associated with the project. Commissioner Andrea Lofthouse-Quesada also abstained because of the open space concerns. Commissioner Danny Tang was absent during the hearing.

At the end of the Planning Commission’s July 1 meeting, Linda Paquette, a friend of Singh’s and a member of the Gurdwara, reiterated to the Commission during public comment that there is indeed an active community of worship there. She also said that worshipers didn’t know about the plans the owner had for the property.

“All it would have taken was a notice posted on their door, where they go in and out and practice and pray and all of that,” Paquette said.

The only notice was around a tree on the sidewalk in front of the Gurdwara. Because many worshippers enter the Gurdwara from the back parking lot, they did not see it until it was too late.

This is what Singh told the Alhambra Source at the All India Cafe in Pasadena, which he owns and manages with his family. He said that he didn’t find out about Lau’s plans to develop the property until Paquette, who heard from another friend attending the June 17 hearing, let him know.

Singh called the city, and was told that the project had already been voted on. He has seen Lau several times since the hearing, to repair a gas line at the Gurdwara. He said that Lau had not mentioned any development project at all.

The city is required to notify all property owners of hearings for potential developments within a 300-foot radius. Since Singh rents the property on behalf of the Gurdwara, the city wasn’t required to notify him.

On Aug. 5, Paquette and Singh both sent letters of complaint to the Planning Commission, the City Council and the Department of Community Development. Paquette said that a notice wrapped around a tree was inadequate and misleading, because in cities like Pasadena, a notice on a tree meant that that tree was being removed. She also criticized the city for misrepresenting the status of the Gurdwara by saying it was vacant, and asked the city to inform them when the community had to move out.

Singh wrote about the uncertainty Alhambra’s Sikh community now faces, because of the lack of notice. “What remedy is there for us for this procedurally defective end to our Gurdwara and its meeting place and living quarters for 300 people?” he asked, telling the Alhambra Source that he wanted to let the city know “that we exist here.”

Marc Castagnola, Alhambra’s director of community development, said that planning staff generally gets their information about properties to be developed from the owner. He said that the letter merely stated the situation and that the issue is between the owner and tenant.

Paquette said that she is researching remedies for this situation, and will continue to follow up with the city.

Singh also met with Sahu, who discussed this meeting on July 15 at the Planning Commission. Sahu brought up the issue of permit applicants not being forthright about including important information concerning their projects. He noted that this can impact the Planning Commission’s decisions.

Other commissioners also brought this up as a concern, with several members advocating for the city revising its notification process, including expanding the notification radius. This also came up in the dispute over the application for the 801 E. Main Street development, which the commission eventually denied.

Planning Commissioner Scott Chan told the Alhambra Source that if he knew that the Gurdwara was still very active, he would have at least asked to delay a vote in order to find out more information. “The displacement of a community institution such as this should not have been voted on so easily that night,” he said in an email.

During the Aug. 5 Planning Commission meeting, Alhambra City Planner Scott Quyle said that staff is revamping its notification procedures, requiring project applicants to provide mailing labels not only for property owners, but tenants as well. Staff was also looking into posting four foot by six foot signs on properties so that they are more noticeable. The city is also looking into increasing the notification radius from 300 feet, which would require City Council action.

This might come too late for the Gurdwara, which would have to move before construction begins. Singh doesn’t know where they’d find a new building with affordable rent that would have the required rooms for prayer and space to prepare and serve a large amount of meals.

“It’s really scary for us,” he said.

Update on August 26, 2019: The article has been corrected to reflect that the Planning Commission vote was 7 to 2, not 8 to 2 as originally stated.

Independent journalism is a bedrock of democracy--and it's in crisis. Here at the Alhambra Source, we're committed to covering the local stories that matter most to you. We don’t have advertisers and we don’t have pay walls, but we do have bills. You read to the end of this story. That's great. But this kind of journalism will end without public support. Join us! Support the work and the democratic values it serves. Donate now!

The Alhambra Source encourages comment on our stories. However, we do not vet comments for accuracy or endorse links to posts in the comment section. The thoughts and opinions expressed belong solely to the author of the comment.

Leave a Reply

4 thoughts on “Alhambra’s Sikh Community May Be Displaced by Condo Development”

  1. This exposed the ignorance, even incompetence, of the city officials and staff. They are not familiar with the city. They live in a house in Alhambra, but they don’t live in Alhambra. They work for the government of Alhambra, but they don’t work for Alhambra. We are talking about some place in downtown Alhambra, not some remote corner far away; and they had no idea what there is. These folks must be just sitting in their air-conditioned offices 9 to 5 and never venture into the parks, restaurants, churches, markets, community center, … in the city. And they did not care to do any due diligence. “It’s really scary for us.” Let me make a suggestion: Require these decision-makers to publish a report every month listing the places in Alhambra they visit and the problems, e.g., graffiti, traffic, parking, broken toilet in the park, they notice. If they care to open their eyes, they certainly will see something.

  2. Once again a minority population of our community is rail roaded unexpectantly for the benefit of over development. When are we going to realize as both an institution and community that our real assets lie in the human capitol that reside in our our community rather than the accumulation of capitol for the few.

  3. Thank you to the Alhambra Source for covering this story. Most of us would never have known about it otherwise. A free press is so important to transparency and accountability in government. It was really accidental that a friend of a member of the congregation happen to be in the audiance that night and convey to the temple that they were being evicted. Bad notification laws would surely continue if the public and press do not expose them. Let’s hope the city improves its abismal project notification policies so that this never happens again.

  4. Kudos to the Planning Commission and the staff for pushing for the revision of the notification procedures. Having large signs posted for projects has long been needed in the city. The developer for the 801 E. Main Street could have avoided much of the opposition he encountered if he had been more transparent with the neighborhood. Working together with the people who are affected by large projects is the way to go.